We use cookies. These cookies enhance your experience and improve our website. Certain cookies are necessary and can't be turned off, but we also allow others to place cookies to track the performance of our website and deliver personalized content and ads. You can select your preference using the buttons.


At Citarella, our cheese selection is more than just bountiful: it’s carefully curated by a cheesemonger with decades of experience. Our discerning buyer chooses the finest cheeses from around the world — those with exceptional flavor and texture — offering you a selection that's extensive (we carry more than 300 cheeses) yet tightly focused on superior quality.
We're passionate about sourcing the finest, showcasing the absolute best in every category of cheese.
Having tasted many gourmet selections, our cheesemonger waits for remarkable finds — ones that will excite your senses. We offer many items from noteworthy creameries around the globe: black truffle-injected wheels of Moliterno from Italy, beautifully crafted Manchegos from Spain, cloth-bound Cheddars from Vermont, and more. Whether you’re looking for a tangy French blue such as Roquefort or a creamy log of goat cheese from New England, you’ll find everything from mild, milky burrata to nutty Swiss in our gourmet market. When visiting our cheese counter, you’ll see an exciting variety of wheels, hand-cut wedges, blocks, and logs as well as a wonderful selection of artisanal accompaniments.
We also offer fully prepared international cheese boards (each one serving serve 1-2 people) — a delicious way to explore cheeses from a distinct region. Each one packaged with sea salt flatbreads and fig jam, you’ll find cheeses like dense Piave and soft Taleggio from Italy, olive oil-rubbed Tres Leches and buttery Mahon from Spain, and earthy St. Nectarine and supple Comté from France.
Whether you want a cheese expert to guide you through the boundless flavors from aound the globe or are looking to pick up a wedge of your favorite fromage, our impressive international cheese selection is guaranteed to delight!
Visit Our Markets
We have the best neighbors! Stop in and say hello. Our knowledgeable staff and friendly managers are always happy to guide you. Come visit us at any one of our locations in NYC, the Hamptons, and Connecticut!





