We use cookies. These cookies enhance your experience and improve our website. Certain cookies are necessary and can't be turned off, but we also allow others to place cookies to track the performance of our website and deliver personalized content and ads. You can select your preference using the buttons.
We carry an extensive selection of wholesome local as well as certified organic dairy products. Enjoy our farm-fresh assortment, from organic milk, butter, and cottage cheese to sour cream, and yogurt. Our smooth, creamy cups of yogurt are cultured right outside the city, and our perfectly sweet organic chocolate milk begins with cows grazing freely. Citarella takes great pride in knowing our producers by name and the story behind their products.
We source the highest quality dairy, fresh from the farm.
Organic dairy farming is better for the environment, better for farm animals, and better for you. When farms use land and resources responsibly (and raise their cattle on a wholesome, organic diet) the result is fresh dairy products that are naturally additive-free, antibiotic-free, and hormone-free — and delicious!
From the highest quality ingredients for your recipes when you’re baking from scratch to a grab-and-go item that you can enjoy as a healthy, protein-rich, midday snack, you’ll find a variety of local and organic dairy options at Citarella.
Visit Our Markets
We have the best neighbors! Stop in and say hello. Our knowledgeable staff and friendly managers are always happy to guide you. Come visit us at any one of our locations in NYC, the Hamptons, and Connecticut!
